Skip to main content

CBDT Withdraws Circular on Share Valuation After Cong Claims ‘Win’

Days after issuing a circular that sought to clarify taxes on valuations, the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) withdrew it following a Congress party press conference at which it said the move would exonerate Rahul and Sonia Gandhi over income-tax liabilities in the Associated Journals Ltd (AJL) case. The withdrawal means that the taxman will again start challenging valuations in cases where there was a fresh issuance of shares. Experts said the withdrawal of the circular has created confusion for several companies that had received tax demands on valuations.
“I don’t know why the government is creating so much confusion in the investing space. Just a simple clarification was required so that genuine investments from listed companies, Sebi-registered AIFs (Alternative Investment Funds), holding companies into subsidiaries, angel funds into DIPP-registered startups, other similar investments should have been made exempt,” said Jeenendra Bhandari, partner, MGB, a chartered accountancy firm. “This process of issuing circulars and then withdrawal is confusing to the investment climate.” Experts said tax regulations had been modified in 2010 to prevent money laundering. The government had inserted a regulation — Section 56(2)(viia) — in the income tax Act to tackle black money transactions in investment situations.
“The section under the income tax Act was originally brought in to curb black money transactions and tax was in the hands of the recipient,” said Girish Vanvari, founder of tax advisory firm Transaction Square. “The withdrawal of the clarification would mean all those who have received tax demands will have to litigate and apply for a stay on the demand.” ET had on January 3 reported that several companies that had received tax notices and faced tax outgo over valuations would get relief thanks to the clarification issued on December 31. It was withdrawn through another circular issued on the night of January 4. Experts said the original clarification only dealt with unintended implications of income tax rules. “The unintended consequence of the income tax provision was that it could have been invoked even in case of fresh issue of shares,” said Amit Maheshwari, partner, Ashok Maheshwary and Associates LLP. “This clarification would have been binding on the tax department and hence would have resolved pending litigation under this clause.”
Many experts said the shift on the valuation issue was mainly due to the press conference by Congress. Party leader Ahmed Patel and Vivek Tankha, head of Congress’ legal cell, had said that the December 31 clarification had vindicated the party’s stand. Tax demands raised on party chief Rahul Gandhi and Sonia Gandhi for receiving shares of AJL’s National Herald were not justifiable, it said. “This vindicates our position that there never was an issue about issuance of such shares as a taxable event as it was being projected by way of harassment. We thank CBDT for this clarification,” the party member had said.

The Economic Times, 7th January 2019


Popular posts from this blog

SC order on RBI circular: More options for banks to tackle defaulting firms

Lenders also have the option of restructuring the loans Lenders to companies which are under stress could now have three options to deal with them if they default on loans: take a haircut as part of a one-time settlement, restructure the loans for a longer tenure as they did when corporate debt restructuring schemes were allowed, or go to the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) for redress. These changes in the options available to lenders come, according to PE funds and bank lawyers who are involved in the IBC process, in the wake of the Supreme Court on Tuesday setting aside the 12 February RBI circular, which allowed a 180-day window to banks to resolve a company default.But they can still find a resolution. According to a Reserve Bank of India circular, a loan becomes a non-performing asset when banks cannot find a way of recovering their money in 90 days. In short, banks still have a window to resolve the default. Lenders can take a haircut as part of a one -time settlement of du…

April GST collections at new high despite rate rationalisation in December

Goods and services tax (GST) collection touched a record high in April, exceeding Rs 1 trillion for the third time in four months. The mop-up was 10 per cent higher over the previous year. Gross collection for the month was Rs 1.13 trillion, said the finance ministry. Despite the recent rate rationalisation in December, a rise in collection was reported. Of the total collected, the CGST (central GST) contributed Rs 21,163 crore, the SGST (state GST) Rs 28,801 crore, the IGST (integrated GST) Rs 54,733 crore (including Rs 23,289 crore on import) and cess Rs 9,168 crore (including Rs 1,053 crore on import). After settlement of the IGST and the balance IGST in a 50:50 ratio between the Centre and states on a provisional basis, the CGST stood at Rs 47,533 crore and SGST at Rs 50,776 crore. The CGST target in the Union Budget for 2019-20 is Rs 6.1 trillion. “The April collection indicates the tax base is increasing gradually, with GST getting stabilised with measures such as e-way bills and…

Shrinking footprints of foreign banks in India

Shrinking footprints of foreign banks in India Foreign banks are increasingly shrinking their presence in India and are also becoming more conservative than private and public sector counterparts. While many of them have sold some of their businesses in India as part of their global strategy, some are trying to keep their core expertise intact. Others are branching out to newer areas to continue business momentum.For example, HSBC and Barclays Bank in India have got out of the retail business, whereas corporate-focused Standard Chartered Bank is now trying to increase its focus on retail “Building a retail franchise is a huge exercise and takes a long time. You cannot afford to lose it,” said Shashank Joshi, Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ’s India head.According to the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) data, foreign banks’ combined loan book shrunk nearly 10 per cent from Rs 3.78 trillion in fiscal 2015-16 to Rs 3.42 trillion last financial year. The banking industry, which includes foreign banks…