Skip to main content

Clause in Aadhaar Act Badly Drafted, says Supreme Court

By
Clause in Aadhaar Act Badly Drafted, says Supreme Court
Section 59 is badly drafted... It is very difficult for us to recognise that fundamental rights can be compromised or waived: CJI Dipak Misra Should court not accept the deemed valid clause, all pre-Act Aadhaar would become suspect in the eyes of the law
The Supreme Court on Tuesday faulted a clause in the Aadhaar Act, which validated all biometric enrolments even before the law was enacted with retrospective effect, as badly drafted and too wide in a prima facie observation.The Act came into effect only in 2016, though the government started enrolling people under its Aadhaar scheme in 2010. Should the court not accept the deemed valid clause, all pre-Act Aadhaar would become suspect in the eyes of the law.
Section 59 of the Act deems consent in all pre-2016 cases where biometrics were collected without the backing of any law. “Section 59 is badly drafted,” observed Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra, who is heading a bench of five judges hearing a batch of petitions challenging the legality of Aadhaar. “It is very difficult for us to recognise that fundamental rights can be compromised or waived,” he said, referring to the deemed consent clause.
The bench was told that Aadhaar was collected in the initial phase in 2010 with enrolment forms that had no reference to biometrics.“Though it was not in the forms, no one was enrolled for Aadhaar without biometrics,” attorney general KK Venugopal told the bench. The Aadhaar enrolment form was changed thrice, the court was told. The reference to biometrics came later.
The AG is now arguing against the court declaring all pre-2016 Aadhaar illegal and invalid. Should the court do so, all the biometrics collected from people before that would have to be destroyed. The government wants to avoid this.“This would be an exercise in futility,” the AG said. “The government will then have to collect the data all over again.”
The AG had so far argued that in the absence of a law, people voluntarily enrolled themselves for Aadhaar. There was no fundamental right to privacy then, he argued. Consequently, no eyebrows can be raised about the alleged intrusion into privacy.He also argued that assuming that it was a precious legal right, the state could for legitimate reasons put reasonable restrictions on such rights. The AG concluded his arguments on Tuesday. Additional solicitor general Tushar Mehta continued arguments defending the scheme as necessary to protect India’s financial security. He will continue arguments Wednesday
The Economic Times, New Delhi, 11th April 2018

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Household debt up, but India still lags emerging-market economies: RBI

By
  Although household debt in India is rising, driven by increased borrowing from the financial sector, it remains lower than in other emerging-market economies (EMEs), the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) said in its Financial Stability Report. It added that non-housing retail loans, largely taken for consumption, accounted for 55 per cent of total household debt.As of December 2024, India’s household debt-to-gross domestic product ratio stood at 41.9 per cent. “...Non-housing retail loans, which are mostly used for consumption purposes, formed 54.9 per cent of total household debt as of March 2025 and 25.7 per cent of disposable income as of March 2024. Moreover, the share of these loans has been growing consistently over the years, and their growth has outpaced that of both housing loans and agriculture and business loans,” the RBI said in its report.Housing loans, by contrast, made up 29 per cent of household debt, and their growth has remained steady. However, disaggregated data sho...
Post a Comment
Read more

External spillovers likely to hit India's financial system: RBI report

By
  While India’s growth remains insulated from global headwinds mainly due to buoyant domestic demand, the domestic financial system could, however, be impacted by external spillovers, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) said in its half yearly Financial Stability Report published on Monday.Furthermore, the rising global trade disputes and intensifying geopolitical hostilities could negatively impact the domestic growth outlook and reduce the demand for bank credit, which has decelerated sharply. “Moreover, it could also lead to increased risk aversion among investors and further corrections in domestic equity markets, which despite the recent correction, remain at the high end of their historical range,” the report said.It noted that there is some build-up of stress, primarily in financial markets, on account of global spillovers, which is reflected in the marginal rise in the financial system stress indicator, an indicator of the stress level in the financial system, compared to its p...
Post a Comment
Read more

Retail inflation cools to a six-year low of 2.82% in May on moderating food prices

By
  New Delhi: Retail inflation in India cooled to its lowest level in over six years in May, helped by a sharp moderation in food prices, according to provisional government data released Thursday.Consumer Price Index (CPI)-based inflation eased to 2.82% year-on-year, down from 3.16% in April and 4.8% in May last year, data from the Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation (MoSPI) showed. This marks the fourth consecutive month of sub-4% inflation, the longest such streak in at least five years.The data comes just days after the Reserve Bank of India’s (RBI) Monetary Policy Committee cut the repo rate by 50 basis points to 5.5%, its third straight cut and a cumulative reduction of 100 basis points since the easing cycle began in February. The move signals a possible pivot from inflation control to supporting growth.Food inflation came in at just 0.99% in May, down from 1.78% in April and a sharp decline from 8.69% a year ago.A Mint poll of 15 economists had projected CPI ...
Post a Comment
Read more