Skip to main content

HC upholds ICDS validity but strikes down key provisions

HC upholds ICDS validity but strikes down key provisions
The Delhi High Court has upheld the constitutional validity of the Income Computation and Disclosure Standards (ICDS), but only to the extent that they do not go against judicial pronouncements and the provisions of the IncomeTax (IT) Act.These standards played a key role in improving India´s position in the World Bank´s ease of doing business rankings, released recently.
“The ICDS is not meant to overrule the provisions of the (Income Tax) Act, the rules thereunder, and the judicial precedents applicable thereto as they stand,” said the court on Wednesday, striking down the ICDS provisions that went against judicial pronouncements and the ITAct.Hearing the petitions filed by the Chamber of Tax Consultants and others, the court also said wherever the ICDS amends the judicial pronouncements and ITprovisions, it should be brought by the legislature and not the executive.
For instance, the court struck down ICDS I, which does away with the concept of prudence,akey accounting principle to ensure assets and income are not overstated and liabilities and expenses not understated.According to this principle,acompany might provide for bad and doubtful debts based on prudence, due to a doubt regarding non-realisation of sales booked in earlier years
This is not allowed, as deduced by the ICDS.The court said, “ICDS I, which does away with the concept of ´prudence´, is contrary to the (IT) Act and binding judicial precedents and is, therefore, unsustainable in law.” Under ICDS I, expected and mark to market losses are not allowed as a deduction, even though standard accounting principles generally allow it.The court also held ICDS II ultra vires.
This standard pertains to the valuation of inventories and eliminates the distinction between a continuing partnership business and the one after a partner quits.This is contrary to the decision of the Supreme Court in Shakti Trading Co. case, said the court.
“ICDS II is held to be ultra vires the Act and struck down as such,” it said.Ajay Singh, president of the Chamber, said the court was fair enough to restrict the powers of the Centre to notify the ICDS so far as those were contrary to judicial pronouncements and the provisions of the ITAct.
When asked whether the Chamber,a not for profit organisation with its mandate to disseminate knowledge in the field of taxation and other fields, would appeal against the court upholding the constitutional validity of the standards, he said it was still studying the finer points of the judgment.
The court also ordered against a provision in ICDS IV which requires an assessee to recognise income from export incentive in the year of making of the claim if there is “reasonable certainty” of its ultimate collection.“The ITAct provides enabling provisions to simplify computation of taxable income, thereby making the ICDS a delegated legislation.
Hence, the ICDS cannot provide for taxation which is not within the ambit of the provisions of the ITAct or accounting principles,” said Pranay Bhatia, partner, tax and regulatory services, BDO India.Amit Maheshwari of Ashok Maheswary &Associates said, “The court verdict would make the life of taxpayers simpler, and the fear that the established tax positions would be undermined is somewhat reduced.” The ICDS have 10 standards, which basically advance some income and postpone some expenses to arrive at the profitability of companies.
Earlier, tax accounting was done on a conservative basis to recognise income as and when it arose.“This is a big relief as the combination of IndAS, ICDS, and IFRS have led toalot of confusion within the industry.To my mind, ICDS should ideally be deferred till IndAS settles in,” said Girish Vanvari, partner and head –tax, KPMG India.IndAS, or Indian Accounting Standards, are adopted by Indian companies and issued by the country´s Accounting Standards Board
IFRS, or International Financial Reporting Standards, are global accounting standards issued by the IFRS Foundation and the International Accounting Standards Board.
Helped India improve on World Bank´s ease of doing business ranking
Court strikes down provisions that go against judicial pronouncements in the ITAct
Changes to judicial pronouncements and ITprovisions should come via the legislature and not the executive
ICDS comes into effect from the current assessment year –201718
ICDS advances some revenues and postpones some expenditure for taxation
The Business Standard, New Delhi, 09th November 2017


Popular posts from this blog

Shrinking footprints of foreign banks in India

Shrinking footprints of foreign banks in India Foreign banks are increasingly shrinking their presence in India and are also becoming more conservative than private and public sector counterparts. While many of them have sold some of their businesses in India as part of their global strategy, some are trying to keep their core expertise intact. Others are branching out to newer areas to continue business momentum.For example, HSBC and Barclays Bank in India have got out of the retail business, whereas corporate-focused Standard Chartered Bank is now trying to increase its focus on retail “Building a retail franchise is a huge exercise and takes a long time. You cannot afford to lose it,” said Shashank Joshi, Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ’s India head.According to the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) data, foreign banks’ combined loan book shrunk nearly 10 per cent from Rs 3.78 trillion in fiscal 2015-16 to Rs 3.42 trillion last financial year. The banking industry, which includes foreign banks…

RBI rushes in to prop up falling rupee

RBI rushes in to prop up falling rupee India’s central bank reportedly intervened in the currency markets on Monday to prevent a further slide in the local unit, which breached the 67 mark to a dollar for the first time in 15 months amid a widening trade gap and runaway import bills fuelled by high crude-oil prices. Some state-owned banks were seen selling dollars aggressively, interventions that market dealers attributed to the central bank’s strategy to stem the decline of the Indian rupee against the US currency. The rupee is the worst performing among a dozen Asian monetary units in the past three months. It lost 4.25 per cent to the dollar during the period, show data from Bloomberg. On Monday, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is said to have sold about Rs 800 million collectively on the spot and exchange traded futures markets, dealers said. An email sent to RBI remained unanswered until the publication of this report. The currency market has seen such a strong central bank interven…

GST Refund of Rs 20,000 Cr Pending: Exporters’ Body

GST Refund of Rs  20,000 Cr Pending: Exporters’ Body Refund of over Rs 20,000 crore on account of Goods and Services Tax (GST) is pending with the government with more than half the amount stuck as input tax credit, Federation of Indian Export Organisations said on Tuesday. While claims over Rs7,000 crore were cleared in March, the amount was Rs 1,000 crore in April.However, after exporters’ request, the GST council and tax department are organizing a second phase of Special Refund Fortnight starting May 31, which will enable exporters to draw their refunds at a speedy pace. Many exporters have been unable to file the refund of input tax credit due to technical glitches, exports and claim happened in different months. The major challenge lies on ITC refund especially because the process is partly electronic and partly manual which is cumbersome and add to the transaction cost, the exporters’ body said. On IGST, refunds are getting delayed due to airline and shipping companies not submitt…