Skip to main content

Coffee-Toffee, the GST Debate Continues

Hundreds of crores of rupees in the form of taxes ride on the exact categorisation of products
Is Parachute hair oil or edible oil? Is KitKat a chocolate or a biscuit? Is a Vicks tablet medicament or confectionery? For the taxpayer and the tax collector, this is much more than an exercise in semantics -hundreds of crores of rupees ride on the exact categorisation.
As the government moves closer to rolling out the goods and services tax (GST) on July 1, many such distinctions are being debated so that no ambiguity remains. Not just that, the government is revisiting old tax cases that were lost over product categorisation, according to people with knowledge of the matter, presumably with a view to making sure that revenue collections can be maximised.
“In the past, several tax officers had challenged some of the product categorisations, including those in the retail segment, but lost out in court or at appellate level,“ said one of the persons. “Now we have a chance to go ahead with specifying the products in a way based on the old cases so that similar situations don't arise.“
It is understood that the product categorisation exercise, which was expected to have been completed last year, is taking much longer because of this process. The rates have already been decided -nil, 5%, 12%, 18% and 28% --but product categorisation is yet to be finalised.
“The GST rates for each and every item are not yet decided as the government is categorising products and what rates can be applied on each category of goods,“ said MS Mani, senior director, Deloitte Haskins & Sells. “There is a chance that some of the old issues raised by the tax department regarding category of certain goods may come back to haunt some companies or products as GST is a new law and can redefine rates and what goods would fall under its preview.“
Some states have also raised issues on this front, Kerala being a case in point. During a re cent closed-door meeting on product categorisation, finance minister TM Thomas Isaac brought up a point highly pertinent to people of that state.
Coconut oil shouldn't be categorised as hair oil but as edible oil, he is reported to have said. The reason? Edible oil and hair oil are taxed differently as the latter is not an essential commodity. But coconut oil is an essential ingredient of Kerala cuisine, making its categorisation a matter of keen public interest for the state's people.
Key past cases are being researched by the GST committee before it decides on the exact tax rates for each category , said the people cited above. This could mean disputes that many companies thought had been resolved coming back to life. Whether such moves will be challenged or not y the companies is yet to be seen. However, ex by the companies is yet to be seen. However, experts said this may be difficult since GST is a new tax regime altogether and old rulings may not have the force of precedent. Some of the old cases being examined involve Marico, P&G, Nestle, Paras Pharmaceuticals and Dabur, according to the people with knowledge of the matter.
For the record: KitKat is a biscuit and Vicks a medicament. In the KitKat case -Nestle (India) Ltd vs Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai, 1999 -it was ruled that the product was a biscuit and not a chocolate, which is taxed at a higher rate.
Meanwhile, companies are lobbying the government to categorise biscuits as essential products under GST, which would mean their being taxed at a lower 5%.
Economic Times New Delhi,25th March 2017


Popular posts from this blog

At 18%, GST Rate to be Less Taxing for Most Goods

About 70% of all goods and some consumer durables likely to cost less

A number of goods such as cosmetics, shaving creams, shampoo, toothpaste, soap, plastics, paints and some consumer durables could become cheaper under the proposed goods and services tax (GST) regime as most items are likely to be subject to the rate of 18% rather than the higher one of 28%.

India is likely to rely on the effective tax rate currently applicable on a commodity to get a fix on the GST slab, said a government official, allowing most goods to make it to the lower bracket.

For instance, if an item comes within the 12% excise slab but the effective tax is 8% due to abatement, then the latter will be considered for GST fitment.

Going by this formulation, about 70% of all goods could fall in the 18% bracket.

The GST Council has finalised a four-tier tax structure of 5%, 12%, 18% and 28% but has left room for the highest slab to be pegged at 40%. A committee of officials will work out the fitment and the council…

Deposit gush:-CA Institute Bats for Special Audit

Obligation for the Month of April

Event DateActApplicable FormObligation07/04/2017Income TaxForm No.27C (TCS)Submission of Forms received in Mar  to IT Commissioner10/04/2017ExciseER-1Excise Return ER-1 for Non SSI assessees for Mar10/04/2017ExciseER-2Excise Return ER-2 for EOUs for Mar10/04/2017ExciseER-3Submission of Excise Return ER-3 by SSI units for Mar quarter10/04/2017ExciseER-6Excise Return ER-6 by units paying duty >  1 crore (CENVAT + PLA) for Mar12/04/2017D-VATBE - 2Advance information for 2nd fortnight of APR of functions with booking cost > Rs 1 lakh in Banquet Halls,hotels etc. in Delhi15/04/2017Income TaxForm 15CCStatement by Banks etc. in respect of foreign remittances during the quarter15/04/2017D-VATDVAT-20Payment of DVAT TDS for Mar15/04/2017Providend FundElectronic Challan cum Return (ECR)E-Payment of PF for Mar21/04/2017ESIESI ChallanPayment of ESI of Mar (Applicable for Salary upto Rs. 21,000 instead of 15,000 earlier)21/04/2017M-VATMVAT ChallanPayment of MVAT & WCT TDS for Mar21/04/201…