Skip to main content

A run-up-to-GST Budget

Budget 2017-18 may turn out to be one of the most trend-setting Budgets to be presented by the National Democratic Alliance government. This is the first time that the Railway Budget has been merged with the Central Finance Budget and there is no distinction between Plan and nonPlan expenditure. This apart, the Budget would be presented on February 1, almost a month earlier than the usual date. Further, preceded by the historic move of demonetisation and expected to be followed by the path-breaking tax reform of goods and services tax (GST), this Budget carries high expectations for both consumers and business owners.
With the conclusion of the GST Council’s last meeting, the tax reform’s journey towards realisation has progressed substantially. Resolution between the Centre and the states on the much-debated issue of sharing administrative control over taxpayers should also set the pace to reach the remaining milestones and for the government to roll out GST. The decision that states will assess more than 90 per cent of small taxpayers with turnover below Rs.1.5 crore is welcome and in line with the existing scheme of indirect taxation in the country. At present, the Centre does not assess manufacturers with turnover of up to Rs.1.5 crore, as they are exempted from excise duty. The challenge for the state tax authorities would be to gear up to assess taxation of services where most of the small service providers fall in the lower bracket and who have been assessed only by the central tax authorities so far.

The next major steps for the GST Council would be to finalise the draft of the GST law, supporting legislations and tax rate schedules for various goods and services in accordance with an already decided multi-rate structure. The realistic timeline for the nationwide rollout of GST was pushed by a quarter to July 1. This short deferment was indeed required, as this would provide the much-needed time for analysis and preparedness for both the government and the businesses.

Budget 2017-18 might be the last one before the country moves to a GST regime. This means it is the last opportunity for the government to further realign the existing tax structure for a smooth transition. Any major amendments such as further introduction and/or increase in rates of cesses or restrictions on availability of credit, which lead to cascading of taxes and are against the spirit of GST, are uncalled for.

The central government has in the last couple of years taken several legislative and administrative measures to foster ease of doing business. However, recent amendments in service tax law around taxability of certain cross-border transactions came as a surprise for various service providers, who were given little time to prepare for critical changes in their tax positions and compliances. These included taxability of digital services provided by overseas service providers to Indian customers, tour operator services and inbound transportation of goods through sea routes in which no Indian person was involved as a contractual party to the service agreement. With the existing regime set to lapse in a few months, having these kinds of sudden tax changes may not only lead to higher tax uncertainty but could also distort the outlook of overseas investors towards India as an emerging market and investment destination. These kinds of amendments should be brought in at a stage so that industry does not panic. At this point, the government should try to improve the existing machinery for processing refund claims and introduce measures for timely conclusion of pending cases to minimise their spillover into GST.

Other expectations from this Budget include realignment of existing cesses such as Swachh Bharat Cess on services and infrastructure cess on automobiles to bring down the cascading of taxes. Creditable cesses such as Krishi Kalyan Cess and NCCD should be made more fungible to allow their credit against other taxes. This would help reduce possible rollover/lapse of credit for these cesses with the taxpayers on the GST cut-over date.

As services could possibly attract up to 18 per cent of tax rate under GST, a marginal increase in service tax rate may be announced to rationalise it further with GST. However, it could be a risky proposition as the tax rate would increase without a commensurate increase in efficiencies that GST would provide to service providers. This might increase the tax burden substantially for the end consumers, who may be hoping for some tax relief given that demonetisation caused them great inconvenience. Post demonetisation, India has witnessed multifold surge in the use of digital payments, including mobile wallets, debit and credit cards and NEFTs. While the government has already extended certain tax concessions to promote digital payments, further benefits on service tax, excise and Customs should be provided for the economy dealing with cash crunch.

The overall expectation of industry from this Budget is further realignment of the existing indirect tax structure with GST framework without radical changes, as it remains busy preparing for this tax reform.

The author is leader, Indirect Tax, BMR & Associates LLP. With inputs from Poonam Harjani, director, and Himanshu Gupta, associate, BMR & Associates LLP.
Business Standard New Delhi,25th January 2017


Popular posts from this blog

SC order on RBI circular: More options for banks to tackle defaulting firms

Lenders also have the option of restructuring the loans Lenders to companies which are under stress could now have three options to deal with them if they default on loans: take a haircut as part of a one-time settlement, restructure the loans for a longer tenure as they did when corporate debt restructuring schemes were allowed, or go to the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) for redress. These changes in the options available to lenders come, according to PE funds and bank lawyers who are involved in the IBC process, in the wake of the Supreme Court on Tuesday setting aside the 12 February RBI circular, which allowed a 180-day window to banks to resolve a company default.But they can still find a resolution. According to a Reserve Bank of India circular, a loan becomes a non-performing asset when banks cannot find a way of recovering their money in 90 days. In short, banks still have a window to resolve the default. Lenders can take a haircut as part of a one -time settlement of du…

April GST collections at new high despite rate rationalisation in December

Goods and services tax (GST) collection touched a record high in April, exceeding Rs 1 trillion for the third time in four months. The mop-up was 10 per cent higher over the previous year. Gross collection for the month was Rs 1.13 trillion, said the finance ministry. Despite the recent rate rationalisation in December, a rise in collection was reported. Of the total collected, the CGST (central GST) contributed Rs 21,163 crore, the SGST (state GST) Rs 28,801 crore, the IGST (integrated GST) Rs 54,733 crore (including Rs 23,289 crore on import) and cess Rs 9,168 crore (including Rs 1,053 crore on import). After settlement of the IGST and the balance IGST in a 50:50 ratio between the Centre and states on a provisional basis, the CGST stood at Rs 47,533 crore and SGST at Rs 50,776 crore. The CGST target in the Union Budget for 2019-20 is Rs 6.1 trillion. “The April collection indicates the tax base is increasing gradually, with GST getting stabilised with measures such as e-way bills and…

Shrinking footprints of foreign banks in India

Shrinking footprints of foreign banks in India Foreign banks are increasingly shrinking their presence in India and are also becoming more conservative than private and public sector counterparts. While many of them have sold some of their businesses in India as part of their global strategy, some are trying to keep their core expertise intact. Others are branching out to newer areas to continue business momentum.For example, HSBC and Barclays Bank in India have got out of the retail business, whereas corporate-focused Standard Chartered Bank is now trying to increase its focus on retail “Building a retail franchise is a huge exercise and takes a long time. You cannot afford to lose it,” said Shashank Joshi, Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ’s India head.According to the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) data, foreign banks’ combined loan book shrunk nearly 10 per cent from Rs 3.78 trillion in fiscal 2015-16 to Rs 3.42 trillion last financial year. The banking industry, which includes foreign banks…