Skip to main content

Making GST lawlitigation-proof

Make Advance Rulings binding on Centre, states

The GST Council has come up with multiple rates for the goods and services tax — zero per cent, five per cent, 12 per cent, 18 per cent and 28 per cent — and also cess. The burden of commodity taxation, such as GST, will have to be ultimately borne by the consumers.

Those who profess simplicity in tax administration will vote for single or dual rates, avoiding disputes. This may be workable in developed countries where population of the poor is small, but not in India. Simplicity in tax administration should not burden the poor and the rich alike. Therefore, there is a need for multiple rates. Different rates of taxation in GST will raise classification disputes, which is unavoidable.

We need to look at the following measures to minimise litigation:

Adopt HSN (Harmonised System of Nomenclature) classifications for commodities, including Interpretative Rules and Explanatory Notes, as binding.

Classification opinions of the CCCN (Customs Cooperation Council Nomenclature) must be made binding.

Establish multiple Advance Ruling (AR) Centres at the central and state levels and make the ARs binding on the department so that there is certainty about the rates. If the ARs themselves have to be revised later on, due to changes in circumstances or law, such changed Rulings should apply only prospectively.

Tax departments at the central and state levels should be discouraged from filing Appeals against classification decisions of the Tribunal.

The writer is managing partner, Lakshmikumaran & Sridharan One of the benefits of introduction of GST was the claim of reduction in litigation. But, the model law falls short of achieving this. Two top litigation aggravators under the model law would be potential valuation disputes and credit restriction on immovable property.

For imported goods, valuation disputes are foreseen given that both GST and the Customs authorities will value them, and there are differences between the respective valuation norms. Further, since inter-state intra-company supplies (goods and services) will be taxable, it will be a major litigation generator as assessees will struggle to decide the taxable base for such supplies, which will be acceptable to the revenue. One hopes that the new draft law provides greater clarity to assessees in this regard.

Coming to credit restriction, the most surprising is the restriction on “goods and/or services acquired by the principal in ….results in .…immovable property, other than plant and machinery”. There is no fathomable reason behind credit restriction on immovable property.

This restriction is also open to criticism for its ambiguity and its consequent ability to generate huge amounts of litigation. To illustrate: (i) What is the ambit of “….immovable property, other than plant and machinery”? Will a thermal power project qualify as ‘plant….’ and not suffer this restriction? A liquefied natural gas storage tank? A gas pipeline? (ii) Who is the ‘principal’? Is it only the ultimate customer or does it cover every contractor down the supply chain vis-a-vis their subcontractor(s)? Credit restriction on immovable property has no place in a value-added-tax regime. One hopes this restriction is removed in the final GST law; at least the restrictions will be clearly enunciated.

The writer is partner & national head, Advaita Legal. Sudipta Bhattacharjee, partner, tax controversy management and contract documentation, also contributed to the article.

The Business Standard New Delhi,07th November 2016

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

New income tax slab and rates for new tax regime FY 2023-24 (AY 2024-25) announced in Budget 2023

  Basic exemption limit has been hiked to Rs.3 lakh from Rs 2.5 currently under the new income tax regime in Budget 2023. Further, the income tax slabs in the new tax regime has been changed. According to the announcement, 5 income tax slabs will be there in FY 2023-24, from 6 income tax slabs currently. A rebate under Section 87A has been enhanced under the new tax regime; from the current income level of Rs.5 lakh to Rs.7 lakh. Thus, individuals opting for the new income tax regime and having an income up to Rs.7 lakh will not pay any taxes   The income tax slabs under the new income tax regime will now be as follows: Rs 0 to Rs 3 lakh - 0% tax rate Rs 3 lakh to 6 lakh - 5% Rs 6 lakh to 9 lakh - 10% Rs 9 lakh to Rs 12 lakh - 15% Rs 12 lakh to Rs 15 lakh - 20% Above Rs 15 lakh - 30%   The revised Income tax slabs under new tax regime for FY 2023-24 (AY 2024-25)   Income tax slabs under new tax regime Income tax rates under new tax regime O to Rs 3 lakh 0 Rs 3 lakh to Rs 6 lakh 5% Rs 6

Jaitley plans to cut MSME tax rate to 25%

Income tax for companies with annual turnover up to ?50 crore has been reduced to 25% from 30% in order to make Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSME) companies more viable and also to encourage firms to migrate to a company format. This move will benefit 96% or 6.67 lakh of the 6.94 lakh companies filing returns of lower taxation and make MSME sector more competitive as compared with large companies. However, bigger firms have shown their disappointment since the proposal for reducing tax rates was to make Indian firms competitive globally and it is the large firms that are competing globally. The Finance Minister foregone revenue estimate of Rs 7,200 crore per annum for this for this measure. Besides, the Finance Minister refrained from removing or reducing Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT), a popular demand from India Inc., but provided a higher period of 15 years for carry forward of future credit claims, instead of the existing 10-year period. “It is not practical to rem

Don't forget to verify your income tax return in August: Here's the process

  An ITR return needs to be verified within 120 days of filing of tax return. Now that you have filed your income tax return, remember to verify it because your return filing process is not complete unless you do so. The CBDT has reduced the time limit of ITR verification to 30 days (from 120 days) from the date of return submission. The new rule is applicable for the returns filed online on or after 1st August 2022. E-verification is the most convenient and instant method for verifying your ITR. However, if you prefer not to e-verify, you have the option to verify it by sending a physical copy of the ITR-V. Taxpayers who filed returns by July 31, 2023 but forget to verify their tax returns, will get the following email from the tax department, as per ClearTax. If your ITR is not verified within 30 days of e-filing, it will be considered invalid, and may be liable to pay a Late Fee. Aadhaar OTP | EVC through bank account | EVC through Demat account | Sending duly signed ITR-V through s