Skip to main content

Regulator wants its penalty discretion back

Plans writing to government for urgent change in the Sebi Act, after nod from board
The Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) plans to write to the central government to change the provisions of its securities laws that deal with the quantum of penalty the market regulator can impose. The matter will be discussed at Sebi's board meeting later this week, according to sources. Following a nod from the board, Sebi might write to the government for ā€˜urgent’ amendments to the Sebi Act, the sources added.
The regulator wants to bring in certain clarifications to ensure that the discretion to impose penalties always lies with its adjudicating officers (AOs). The move could impact cases between 2002 and 2014, a lot of which are still pending before the regulator. The Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT) has also been remanding back matters to Sebi to re-decide and impose higher penalties.
ā€œWe want to insert a clarification that the discretion to impose a penalty has always remained with the adjudicating officer,ā€ said a Sebi official.
Sebi had issued clarifications in the past. For instance, Sebi’s powers to issue disgorgement orders were earlier questioned on grounds that the Sebi Act did not expressly confer this power on the regulator. Consequently, in 2013, the regulator added an explanation to Section 11B of the Act, clarifying that it has and should be deemed to always have had the power to pass disgorgement orders.
Disgorgement is the forced giving up of profits obtained by illegal or unethical acts and a repayment of ill-gotten gains imposed on wrongdoers by the courts.
In a November 26 ruling in the matter of Roofit Industries, the Supreme Court had ruled that Sebi’s adjudicating officer or SAT can no longer use their discretion to consider any factor other than the factors specified in Section 15J while considering the quantum of monetary penalty. This led to a situation where heavy penalties were imposed by the regulator for even minor breaches (for violations between 2002 and 2014).
Interestingly, in an order dated March 14 in the matter of Siddharth Chaturvedi versus Sebi, a two-member division bench of the Supreme Court questioned the arguments used to arrive at the Roofit judgment. The bench questioned whether penalties be solely decided based on the three clauses set out in Section 15J, or whether other relevant circumstances ought to be taken into account.
The Chaturvedi case has now been referred to a three-member bench whose decision could have a bearing on Sebi’s discretionary powers to impose penalties.
ā€œUntil the Supreme Court decides on the issue of discretion in the Siddharth Chaturvedi matter, any interpretation would be premature. However, it is open to the Sebi board to recommend to the finance ministry for taking up a clarification amendment to the Sebi Act and other allied laws to provide clarity to market participants,ā€ said Vaneesa Agrawal, a securities lawyer.
According to experts, the regulator is keen on inserting the necessary clarifications as the Chaturvedi judgment could go either way.
Prior to the Roofit judgment, Sebi and SAT used to examine the facts and the gravity of the offence as well as the conduct and financial condition of the entity before levying the penalty. SAT, at times, reduced the penalty even on humanitarian grounds.
Business Standard New Delhi,18th May 2016

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Budget: Startup sector gets new Fund of Funds, FM to allocate Rs 10K cr

  The Indian startup sector received a boost with Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman announcing the establishment of a new fund of funds (FoF) in the Budget 2025. The minister unveiled a fresh FoF with an expanded scope, allocating Rs 10,000 crore. The initial fund of funds announced by the government with an investment of Rs 10,000 crore successfully catalysed commitments worth Rs 91,000 crore, the minister said.   ā€œThe renewal of the Rs 10,000 crore commitment to the Fund of Funds for alternative investment funds (AIFs) is a significant step forward for the Indian startup and investment ecosystem. The initial Rs 10,000 crore commitment catalysed Rs 91,000 crore in investments, and I fully expect this fresh infusion to attract an additional Rs 1 lakh to Rs 1.5 lakh crore in capital,ā€ said Anirudh Damani, managing partner, Artha Venture Funds.   Damani further added that this initiative will provide much-needed growth capital to early-stage startups, further strengthenin...

After RBI rate cut, check latest home loan interest rates of top banks for loans above Rs 75 lakh

  The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has reduced the repo rate by 25 basis points from 6.50% to 6.25% in its monetary policy review as announced on February 7, 2025. After the RBI repo rate cut, banks such as SBI, Canara Bank, PNB, and Union Bank among others have cut their repo linked lending rates. Most other banks are also expected to cut their lending rates in line with the RBI rate cut. After banks cut their lending rates, their home loan borrowers will have to pay less interest. Normally, when a lender cuts the lending rate, borrowers get two options: Either to go for a reduction in EMIs or reduce the tenure of the loan. The second option will help the borrowers clear their home loan outstanding faster. In case, the borrower goes for reduction in EMI then the lower lending rate of the lender would mean lower Equated Monthly Installment (EMI) for borrowers.   EMI is the amount you will pay on a specific date each month till the loan is repaid in full.A repo rate-linked home ...