Skip to main content

IT Act does not provide for arbitration on tax matters

By
Notices can be issued by tax authorities for various reasons. One such reason can be to effect recovery. This is what Vodafone is facing lately, even when the matter is before arbitration. The moot question, hence, would be — can the department issue a recovery notice, when the dispute is pending before an arbitration panel? The legal answer to this would be a certain ‘yes’.
Once a tax has been determined by revenue authorities as ‘ payable’, it can be recovered, even coercively. The pendency of the case, even before the high court or Supreme Court, does not prevent the recovery of tax. The only remedy is to get the recovery ‘ stayed’ by a court.
It is noteworthy that the Income- tax Act does not provide for any arbitration on tax matters. International arbitrations are generally invoked to protect investments running in astronomical figures — as is the case with Vodafone, which has resorted to the IndiaNetherlands Bilateral Investment Treaty. This arbitration certainly does not put alegal bar on recovery.
Thus, given that the tax notice is legally correct, and the pendency of the matter for arbitration does not prohibit recovery, here is the larger question. As a matter of propriety, whether the government should have hastened such recovery? The answer would be a definite ‘no’. The Income- tax Act does not lay down any timeline for recovery. It is an administrative action and due to various reasons the recovery might be delayed. In other words, it would not be illegal to delay tax recovery, and the fact that the case is pending for arbitration can well be a reason to stall the recovery proceedings.
Besides retrospective amendments, Finance Act 2012 had gone a step further and enacted a validation clause (section 119).
The clause sought to nullify the judgment of the Supreme Court by upholding the previous tax demands raised. The department is well within its rights to enforce the retrospective amendments, applying the validating clause.
The author is a tax consultant with Lakshmikumaran & Sridharan Attorneys, and a former Indian Revenue Service officer.
Business Standard, New Delhi, 29th February 2016

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Govt’s gamble on GST cuts: What do the bond and currency markets signal?

By
  It’s not just humans who suffer from cognitive biases; markets do too. Interestingly, different financial markets exhibit distinct biases, each interpreting events through its own prism of prejudice. Take the recent announcements on GST reforms: equity markets have chosen to view them through the lens of growth, while bond and currency markets are focusing on potential macroeconomic risks—fiscal pressures and current account challenges. So, which lens captures the true pulse?Equity markets may be right in expecting GST reforms to revive consumption, which has remained lacklustre for a while. But the key question remains—will this revival come at the cost of broader macro stability?It is well known that consumption stocks have rallied since the GST rationalisation announcement. But what about bond markets? What signals are they sending since this rejig was announced from the ramparts of the Red Fort?The signs aren't encouraging. Bond prices have slumped and yields have surged sinc...
Post a Comment
Read more

Luxury carmakers urge clarity on GST rates to boost festive season sales

By
  A clear picture regarding new GST rates at the earliest will help the overall auto industry, including the luxury car segment, to regain momentum in the ongoing quarter, which generally sees enhanced sales on account of the festive season.The high-powered GST Council, chaired by Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, will meet on September 3-4 to discuss moving to a two-slab taxation.In an interaction with PTI, BMW Group India President and CEO Hardeep Singh Brar said the recent speculation about the change in GST rates has caused uncertainty in the minds of consumers.Consumer interest and demand is strong, but they (prospective buyers) have adopted a wait-and-watch approach, and this delayed decision-making is impacting new vehicle sales at a certain level, he noted."Expediting clarity on GST rates is essential to get back to speed and ensure the auto sector's contribution to economic growth during this quarter is robust," Brar stated.He also hoped that the sustainable p...
Post a Comment
Read more

Sebi proposes tighter norms for green bond third-party reviewers

By
  Sebi on Friday said it has proposed to tighten the norms to appoint independent third-party reviewers or certifiers for green debt securities to align them with requirements for other ESG-linked bonds.In a draft circular, Sebi said that the current norms for green bonds, introduced in February 2023, lack detailed requirements around reviewer independence, conflict of interest mitigation, and disclosure standards that are now in place for other ESG-linked securities under a June 2025 circular.The regulator's latest proposal seeks public comments on a revised framework that would bring parity by incorporating comprehensive criteria for third-party certifiers of green bonds on non-convertible securities.Under the proposed norms, issuers of green debt securities will need to appoint reviewers who are independent of their management, directors, and key managerial personnel. These reviewers will be remunerated in a way that prevents any conflicts of interest and possess relevant expert...
Post a Comment
Read more