Skip to main content

Bombay HC rules in favour of Vodafone

By
With the high court here ruling in favour of Vodafone in a transfer pricing case, the Indian arm of the British telecom company has scored another victory against tax authorities. The case pertains to the sale of its call centre business to Hutchison’s India entity and assignment of call options to Vodafone International BV in 2007- 08.
The authorities pursued with their tax demands under transfer pricing rules, despite the Supreme Court having ruled against similar cases earlier this year. In fact, Vodafone approached the high court after a fresh demand was made by the authorities this July.
Fereshte D Sethna, senior partner at DMD, legal advisor to Vodafone, said: “ The verdict has reaffirmed justice for Vodafone and is an excellent signal for foreign investors. The high court has struck down the stand of the tax authorities premised inter alia on the fundamental position that tax exigibility of the transaction was already considered by the Supreme Court back in 2012. The tax office stance to bring an Indian subsidiary to tax on the very same transaction was rightly not countenanced by the court.” The ruling has come as a rap on the knuckles of tax authorities for pursuing the case even after the government decided not to pursue similar transfer pricing cases earlier this year.
Following the Supreme Court ruling in 2012 in favour of Vodafone in a $ 2- billion tax case, tax authorities adjusted the valuation of assignment of call options under the transfer pricing rules by Rs.8,500 crore and slapped a fresh tax demand of Rs.3,100 crore on the Indian arm of Vodafone.
CASE HISTORY RESOLVED CASES STILL WAITING
Vodafone: Bombay HCruled in favour of Vodafone, saying itwas not liable to pay ~ 3,100 crore in additional tax in a transfer pricing case Castleton: Got relief on minimum alternate tax ( MAT) after theAP Shah committee in its report said foreign companies withouta permanent establishment or place of business in India should not be liable to pay MAT Cairn: Regarding a tax demand of ~20,495 cr for failing to deduct withholding tax on alleged capital gains.
Matter in international arbitration; government to appoint its arbitrator Nokia: Relates to a tax demand of Rs.21,153 cr over non- deduction of tax at source concerning royalty payments to its then parent, Nokia Oyj Shell: In November 2014, the Indian unit of Royal Dutch Shell Plc won Rs.18,000- cr transfer pricing cases against I- T department. Final call on the matter yet to be taken by the government Sept 2007: Income tax (I- T) department slaps Vodafone International BV with a tax demand of $2 billion Jan 2012: Supreme Court sets aside I- T departments claim, saying transaction carried out of India cannot be taxed Feb 2012: I- T department slaps Rs.3,100- crore tax notice on Vodafone India Sept 2013: Bombay HC dismisses Vodafones petition and refers it back to tax tribunal Dec 2013: Income Tax Appellate Tribunal asks Vodafone to deposit ~200 crore Dec 2014: Tribunal says Vodafone liable for tax payments Sep 2015: High Court sets aside Tribunal order on Vodafone tax notice.
Business Standard, New Delhi, 9th Oct. 2015

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Household debt up, but India still lags emerging-market economies: RBI

By
  Although household debt in India is rising, driven by increased borrowing from the financial sector, it remains lower than in other emerging-market economies (EMEs), the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) said in its Financial Stability Report. It added that non-housing retail loans, largely taken for consumption, accounted for 55 per cent of total household debt.As of December 2024, India’s household debt-to-gross domestic product ratio stood at 41.9 per cent. “...Non-housing retail loans, which are mostly used for consumption purposes, formed 54.9 per cent of total household debt as of March 2025 and 25.7 per cent of disposable income as of March 2024. Moreover, the share of these loans has been growing consistently over the years, and their growth has outpaced that of both housing loans and agriculture and business loans,” the RBI said in its report.Housing loans, by contrast, made up 29 per cent of household debt, and their growth has remained steady. However, disaggregated data sho...
Post a Comment
Read more

External spillovers likely to hit India's financial system: RBI report

By
  While India’s growth remains insulated from global headwinds mainly due to buoyant domestic demand, the domestic financial system could, however, be impacted by external spillovers, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) said in its half yearly Financial Stability Report published on Monday.Furthermore, the rising global trade disputes and intensifying geopolitical hostilities could negatively impact the domestic growth outlook and reduce the demand for bank credit, which has decelerated sharply. “Moreover, it could also lead to increased risk aversion among investors and further corrections in domestic equity markets, which despite the recent correction, remain at the high end of their historical range,” the report said.It noted that there is some build-up of stress, primarily in financial markets, on account of global spillovers, which is reflected in the marginal rise in the financial system stress indicator, an indicator of the stress level in the financial system, compared to its p...
Post a Comment
Read more

Healthy balance sheets augur well for economy: RBI Governor Sanjay Malhotra

By
  Large tariffs by the United States administration and elevated geopolitical risk have increased near-term global financial stability risks, and along with weather events pose downside risks to domestic growth, Reserve Bank of India(RBI) Governor Sanjay Malhotra said in the foreword to the Financial Stability Report released today.Noting that domestic growth momentum is buoyed by strong domestic drivers, sound macroeconomic fundamentals and prudent policies, Malhotra said: “External spillovers and weather-related events could pose downside risks to growth.”On the other hand, he said the outlook for inflation is benign, and there is greater confidence in the durable alignment of inflation with the Reserve Bank’s target.Commenting that the structural shifts reshaping the global economy are making policy intervention challenging, the Governor emphasised the need for central banks and financial sector regulators to remain vigilant, prudent and agile in safeguarding their economies and...
Post a Comment
Read more